- Microtechnics - Sep 25 Learn how to walk
- Medicine - Sep 23 Novartis receives three new FDA approvals for the expanded use of Ilaris treating rare Periodic Fever Syndrome conditions
- Life Sciences - Sep 23 How natural selection acted on one penguin species over the past quarter century
- Earth Sciences - Sep 23 Link between Texas earthquakes and wastewater injection
- Literature - Sep 23 New Drama Season Proves Laughter Is Best Medicine
- Religions - Sep 23 Illinois religion professor looks at Jewish theology of protest in new book
- Business - Sep 23 Rebranding the right: Republicans, and the republic, post- election
- Medicine - Sep 23 Compared with Europe, American teens have high rates of illicit drug use
- Astronomy - Sep 23 Summer fireworks on Rosetta’s comet
- Life Sciences - Sep 23 Biologist receives the Ig Nobel Prize
- Careers - Sep 23 Treatment withdrawal from patients in a permanent vegetative state
- Environment - Sep 23 Trophy hunting of lions can aid in conservation, but overhaul of system is required, say researchers
- Medicine - Sep 23 International grant grows UQ research
- Medicine - Sep 23 Novartis announces positive top- line results from ASCEND-4, a Phase III trial of Zykadia in untreated adult ALK+ NSCLC patients
- Life Sciences - Sep 23 How to power up graphene implants without frying cells
- Medicine - Sep 23 National Eye Health Week – Grant success for unique stem cell therapy
U.S. Court of Appeals rules in favor of the University of Minnesota in case involving the Turkish Coalition of America
MINNEAPOLIS / ST. PAUL (05/03/2012) —The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit ruled in favor of the university today in a closely watched case involving First Amendment and academic freedom claims. The plaintiff in the case, Turkish Coalition of America, claimed that statements on a university department website that suggested that the Turkish Coalition’s information about the Armenian genocide was “unreliable” violated its free speech rights and were defamatory. A university student also allegedly feared he would be subjected to academic reprisals if he used information from the organization’s website in his own work.
The federal district court had previously granted the university’s motion to dismiss the claims, based principally upon its finding that the university’s website contained statements of faculty scholarly opinion and critique that were protected by the doctrine of academic freedom.
The Court of Appeals today affirmed the District Court’s dismissal of the plaintiff’s claims. It found the Turkish Coalition free speech claim failed because it could not show it had suffered any restrictions on its speech activities. The Court of Appeals also found that the Turkish Coalition’s defamation claims failed because the university faculty’s statements were either true or were statements of opinion, which cannot support a defamation claim. The Court of Appeals also found the student had no standing to bring any claims because he could not show he suffered any injury.
The case has been watched closely by scholars around the United States and the world because of its implications for principles of academic freedom.
U of M General Counsel Mark Rotenberg stated, “Today’s federal court decision confirms the right of universities and their faculty to offer scholarly criticism and critique on websites without fear of legal exposure. This protection is especially important when the scholarly opinions expressed by the faculty are controversial. We are very pleased to have successfully defended this important academic interest.”
- © 2009-2012 Regents of the University of Minnesota. All rights reserved.
- The University of Minnesota is an equal opportunity educator and employer
- Last modified on May 3, 2012
Last job offers
- Mathematics - 22.9
Abteilungsleiter/in Mathematik, Natur- und Ingenieurwissenschaften
- Media - 21.9
Faculty Positions in Computer and Communication Science
- Astronomy - 21.9
Professor position in the domain of Hot Universe and Compact Objects
- Social Sciences - 20.9
Wissenschaftliche Mitarbeiterin / Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter (60 - 80%)
- Architecture - 17.9
Professur für Denkmalpflege
- Arts and Design - 16.9
Dozent / Dozentin Gitarre Profil Jazz
- Physics/Materials Science - 23.9
Postdoctoral Research Fellowship in Theoretical Semiconductor Physics
- Chemistry - 23.9
Postdoctoral position: Wettability and pore structure understanding for increased injectivity in Dan...